smi1ey's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[-Motion-]

Best Clay Animation on NG

That's all I have to say. I can't believe how insanely well done that was. Adding to my favs right now.

[CU-Holiday Special 05]

I wish I could give the humor a 25.

I have reviewed almost 400 different animations here on newgrounds, and i've probably watched 25 times that many. I have never laughed during ANY of those other shows as much as I laughed during this. That was absolutely golden. Thanks for cheering me up after a hard day at work, helping morons fix their iPods. *shudders*

[moral sense]

Already Underrated

Fantastic film. I would have liked to see the can's journey a bit more, but that was just so well done it's not even funny. BRAVO.

[Orlando's Joint #3]

Great job man.

This whole series has been awesome, and that was a hilarious way to end it! Way to bring things around full circle. Very well done man, I look forward to your future work.

[Christmas Blonde 3 - Pt 1]

Wow, a Betty Series!

Way to take Betty to the next level! Looking forward to the rest! =)

[Pallid Fingers 2]

Constructive Criticism

First off I wanna let you know this get's a 10 all around. Very well done. A couple ideas though...

I know you're crossing over your own series into the Salad Fingers universe, and that's cool. However, with your skill in recreating that universe, why not try a pure Salad Fingers parady, without adding the new characters? I think you would do a great job if you were to make a parody episode that played out more liks a Salad Fingers (just making fun of it along the way).

Secondly, this episode didn't seem to focus as much on the Salad Fingers style as the first. I was waiting for a random person to "talk" by screaming, or for someone to have a rusty item of some sort.

Finally, I think using the Salad Fingers styled music would have really added to the piece, rather than pop artists instead.

No worries though, still a great piece, and I look forward to more of your work.

rtil responds:

I think the reason I didn't go that far into the Firth universe is that I didn't want to seem like a complete rip off of his style and have people accusing me of simply copying his work. That's why I wanted to mix it with something unorthodox, like the music style.
I know this is a lot different from the first episode (which was made in a day.) Both just kind of went off of a small idea and grew from it with no boundaries. This is a little less weird from the first because it's longer, has some meager excuse for a plot and, well, half the people who watched the first Pallid Fingers simply couldn't get their heads around it. But thank you for the review, and I'm glad you enjoyed it nonetheless.
Expect pretty different cartoons than this one from me in the future.

[Pinch, Blink, Stay Alive]

Beautiful

That last review has to be the most shallow and immature review i've seen on here. "seen some things from spongebob"!? what is he like 5?! that was a fantastic toon. Very well done, and very warm-hearted.

[Primal War]

I still gave it a 5 but...

I couldn't watch the whole thing cuz the song you chose was HORRIBLE! Don't get me wrong, I don't mind hardcore stuff at all, but that song just sucked, and didn't go with the movie at all. But great job on the rest of the movie.

[Halo 3 2:Halo 4 The Movie]

FREAKIN HILARIOUS!

I find it funny how people always give low ratings to movies simply because they don't understand them. That was a stroke of genius, and had me laughing the whole way through! Good to see waterman back in action! =)

[Monkeys In Space]

why isn't this a 4+?!?!

this was absolute comic genius! the writing was fantastic, and the animation was very well done. i don't get these kids who vote good movies like this one below a 4. =( well done!